Neck protection in hockey has been a topic of increasing importance, especially following tragic incidents such as the fatal injury of Adam Johnson in October 2023. While the NHL currently does not mandate the use of neck guards, the debate continues to evolve, with more players opting for this crucial protective gear. Here, we dive into the data, reasons behind the low adoption rates, and the potential for change in the future.
The Current Landscape of Neck Guard Usage in the NHL
As of now, less than 10% of NHL players wear neck guards during games. This estimation is based on anecdotal evidence and reports from the league. Despite high-profile injuries that could have been prevented with neck protection, the majority of players remain hesitant to adopt this gear. The NHL Players' Association has resisted a league-wide mandate, citing comfort concerns and preferences for personal choice over regulatory enforcement.
The Tragic Death of Adam Johnson and Its Aftermath
The unfortunate passing of Adam Johnson from a skate blade injury to his neck has reignited discussions around safety in the sport. In response, a small but growing number of NHL players, including Rasmus Dahlin (Buffalo Sabres), TJ Oshie (Washington Capitals), Jake Wallman (Detroit Red Wings), and others from the Pittsburgh Penguins and Toronto Maple Leafs, have started wearing neck guards voluntarily. While these players represent only a fraction of the league, their choice reflects a broader awareness of safety risks.
Player Resistance: The 2023 NHL Poll
A 2023 NHL player poll revealed that 78% of players are against mandating neck guards in the league. Many athletes cite concerns about discomfort and limitations in mobility, especially when considering the fast-paced, high-contact nature of the sport. Some players believe that current neck guard designs are not well-suited for professional play, contributing to the low adoption rates.
Comfort vs. Safety: The Design Challenge
One of the main barriers to widespread use of neck guards in the NHL is the perceived discomfort. Players often argue that traditional neck guards restrict their range of motion or irritate the skin, which is critical during intense gameplay. However, with advances in materials and design, such as TITANOTEX™️ used in Titan Battlegear’s neck guards, these issues can be addressed. Innovations like Graphene-infused fabrics offer lightweight, flexible, and highly protective solutions, potentially changing the narrative around neck guard usage.
The Role of Safety Mandates: Could Change Be on the Horizon?
While the NHL does not currently mandate neck guards, other leagues and organizations are taking action. For instance, USA Hockey has approved a mandate requiring neck laceration protection for all players under 18 starting in August 2024. Additionally, the IIHF and junior leagues such as the OHL and WHL have implemented similar rules. These moves set a precedent, and it’s likely that the NHL will face increasing pressure to follow suit as player safety becomes a more urgent concern.
The Potential for Future Adoption
Despite the current resistance, neck guard adoption in the NHL could rise as designs improve and awareness grows. The tragic injuries in recent years highlight the real dangers players face on the ice. As protective technology advances, more players may voluntarily choose to wear neck guards, especially if discomfort and performance issues are minimized. Over time, this shift in attitude could lead to a league-wide mandate, much like how helmets were eventually required.
Final Thoughts
While only a small percentage of NHL players currently wear neck guards, the conversation around player safety is far from over. As protective gear technology evolves and more players recognize the benefits of cut-resistant neck protection, we could see a gradual increase in adoption. The recent death of Adam Johnson serves as a stark reminder of the risks, and with leagues like USA Hockey leading the charge, the NHL may eventually follow suit in prioritizing player safety over tradition.
For players and parents alike, making the decision to incorporate advanced neck protection into their gear is becoming increasingly important. Titan Battlegear’s commitment to providing state-of-the-art neck guards, made from materials like TITANOTEX™️, ensures the highest level of cut resistance and comfort for all hockey athletes. Check out our Battlegear Collection for superior neck and wrist protection today.
